19th Century Victorian Italianate Mansion with 5+ suites in the Heart of Amish Country (1M+ annual tourists)

sq. ft.
per sq ft
Heated sq ft: 5,032 sq ft
Avg Nightly Rate:
Home Legally Sleeps: 0
Occupancy Rate: 0 weeks
Annual Gross Income : Inquire
Annual Net Operating Income : Inquire
Property Type: Detached Single Family Home (Villa, Cabin, Cottage)
Ownership Type: Full (100%)
Seasoned Short Term Rental: No
Furnishings Included: No
For Sale By: Broker
Seller Financing: Will Consider
Niche: Couples/Romance, Weddings or Family Reunions
New Construction: Yes
Days on Vrolio: 186

Property Description

This large and beautiful Victorian property has previously been a bed and breakfast in the recent past by the current owners and is TURN-KEY ready for short-term rental. Currently being used as an office, this property has all the trappings for an excellent short-term rental. Located in Millersburg Ohio, 2 blocks from the center of town, this property is in the heart of Ohio's "Amish country" boasting over 1 million visitors each year. Your clientele are shoppers that come from miles to visit the quality products being sold at Amish-owned shops in the area. Products here range from prepared foods to high-quality furniture. The local tourism industry is booming at an incredible rate. See the Holmes County Chamber of Commerce for more information. As a traditional B&B, the owners were booked for months to a year in advance and offered 4 suites, each with its own full bathroom. The full apartment over the 1000 SF garage could make a great long-term rental, a residence for the property's steward, or an additional suite with a kitchen and laundry. Even the garage is currently finished as an efficiency unit. This home is not on the historic registry, so no fuss about modifications. All of the architecture and design of the period are here. Starting on the exterior, the beautiful eaves cornice and the stone window pediments are something to behold. The long screened-in porch is magnificent and features wonderful views of the village. Beautiful landscaping, there's even an heirloom rose bush planted by the original owners. Inside, the stunning grand staircase truly is a work of art with a unique balustrade in pristine condition, original woodwork with maker's mark, the transom windows, and exceptional pocket doors, all make this property one for the history books. You won't have any problem booking this property as it stands today. It's well-cared for and all the important updates are done. The full attic could make an additional couple of suites or whatever you needed with several cranking skylights. There's a ton of earning potential here at an affordable price. Serious buyers only. Call today for a virtual or private walkthrough. STR INFO: From '97- '03 this was used as a traditional bed and breakfast by the current owners. They don't have any records still but did say they had great occupancy without much advertising. Local tourism attracts 1 million-plus visitors a year. There are 4 suites turn-key with their own full bathrooms currently. 2 of the suites have 2 rooms for a possible 4 beds each. 2 of the suites have en-suite baths and 2 have separate hall baths. There's also a full apartment over the garage with kitchen, bathroom, and laundry which could be a 5th suite or a long-term rental for an estimated $800+/month with separate access. This would possibly sleep 16 on double beds if you added a sleeper sofa in the hallway for a full rental. The rates in town for current STR locations run from $111-$169 per night. The owners stopped using it as a B&B due to an opportunity to open a law firm at the location, which they are moving which is why they are selling. 

Presented by:
Joey Marino III
Whipple Realty
Seller Financing
Will Consider
Distress Sale
Seller Financing Terms
Seasonal Nightly Rates
High: 0
Low: 0
Peak: 0
Special Event: 0
Avarage: 0.00
Furniture Age
Est Value of Furnishings
Peak & High Seasons
Ownership Percentage
Full (100%)
Qualifies for foreign national visa
Not sure
Reason for Selling
Seller is moving their business from the property and just looking to sell.
Foreign national buyer restrictions from government?
Not sure
Gross Annual Income
Net Operating Income
Additional Indoor Rooms
Attached Garage for No car, Attached In Law Suite, Formal Dining Room, Living Room, Multiple Master Suites, Unfinished basement
Dryer, Full stove, Oven, Refrigerator, Washer
Central A/C (gas or electric), Central Heat (gas or electric), Wall Unit A/C, Wall Unit Heat
Floor Coverings
Carpet, Real Hardwood
Security Description
Half Baths
Master Suite(s)
Energy Efficiency
Attic air barriers, Skylights
Year built
Outdoor Features
Deck, Porch - Screened, Walk Out Balcony
Backyard Exposure
Lot Size
Small village lot 82' by 92'. There's a small patch of grass in the side yard that can be fenced in if desired.
Community Features
Tax Amount/Year
CDD Amount
Deed Restricted Community
Interview Required
Neighborhood Amenities
Mandatory HOA
Home Legally Sleeps:
Onsite Parking
There are 2-4 spots in the driveway, there are 2 on-street parking, and 3 spaces rented from property next door for $50/month.
Neighborhood Association STR Rules
Municipality STR Rules
No restrictions documented by owner. Verification recomended
Transferrable Permit or License
Yes, Transfers to new owner
Rental Tax Info
Minimum Nightly Rental
No Minimum
Rental Length Requirement
No Restriction
Has Rental History
Established Rental History
Occupancy Rate
Being Sold with Bookings
Caretaker Info
InquireCaretaker cannot stay and oversee the property
Bookings Placed By
Managed By
Management Bookings Percentage
Caretaker Bookings Percentage
Paid Booking History
Property has never had any paid bookings on the home becase The home has been used as a long-term rental
Future Booking Calendar
Management Fees
Caretaker Fees
Sold with Marketing Collateral
Manager Cancellation Policy
Credit Card Fee
Cleaning Fee
Licesnes & Permits (Annual)
Advertising & Tech Costs (Annual)
Yard & Pest Control (Annual)
Pool & Spa Maintinence (Annual)
Electricity (Annual)
Water/Sewer (Annual)
Cable/Interbet (Annual)
Accounting Fee (Annual)
Property Taxes (Annual)
Homeowner's Insurance (Annual)
Short Term Rental Insurance Rider (Annual)
CDD Fee (Annual)
Annual Homeowner's Association Dues
Additional Membership Fees (Annual)
Purchase price
Closing costs
Home Inspection
Furniture & Interiors Package
Rehab Work Estimates
Total Capital Investment

Average Nightly Rent

Weekly Rent

Potential Annual Rent

Weeks Rented (of 52)

Additional Net Revenue Streams

Effective Gross Revenue

Effective Gross Rent

Variable Expenses (Annual)
Management Rental Commission (%)

Management Rental Commission Annually ($)

Credit Card Fee (%)

Credit Card Fee Annually ($)

Cleaning Fee ($ per rented wk)

Cleaning Fees Annually

Booking Site Service Fees (%)

Booking Site Service Fees ($)

Management Fee ($ per mo)

Management Fee Annually

Additional Nightly Insurance Policy ($ per night)

Additional Nightly Insurance Policy Annually

Sales, Bed, Resort, Tourist Tax (%)

Sales, Bed, Resort, Tourist Tax Annually ($)

Fixed Expenses (Annual)
Annual Permits/Licences

Advertising & Tech Costs

Yard and Pest Control

Pool Maintenance





Property Taxes

Homeowner's Insurance

Short Term Rental Insurance Rider

CDD fee

Annual Homeowners Association Dues

Additional Membership Fees

Maintenance Reserves/Supplies


Fixed & Variable Expenses

Down Payment (%)

Down Payment (Capital Investment)

Loan Amount

Interest Rate

Amortization (Loan Years)

Monthly Payment

Annual Debt Service

Average Monthly Cash Flow

Annual Cash Flow

Cash-on-Cash Return

Annual Occupancy to Break Even

Break-Even Occupancy (Weeks)

Net Operating Income (NOI)

Cap Rate (ROI)


User understands this calculator is deemed reliable but not guaranteed. Vrolio makes absolutely no guarantees on returns or income. User should do their own due diligence and verify all data before making a purchasing decision. User understands that this is an educational tool only. We therefore accept no liability arising from any reliance made by any user or person to whom this information is made available to. Please use this tool at your own discretion and use caution always before buying any real estate investment.


Listing Source: Whipple Realty, 330-412-2221

The information featured here is supplied by third party resources. In some cases the owner directly will supply the data and in other cases third party listing sources. While we do everything in our power to ensure the information is as accurate as possible but we can in no capacity, guarantee the information sourced here is 100% accurate. All users should do their own due diligence and further research before engaging in a property purchase based on the data and information provided here. It is deemed reliable but not guaranteed. In many cases the information may not be verified further than the source that provided it to us. This includes all data and information shown about the properties, locations, regulations and any other details found here. Vrolio does not own, manage and is not in any way associated with in a real estate transaction capacity any of the properties shown here. Images are subject to copyright from owner and photographer. We do not own any of the images provided here. We therefore accept no liability arising from any reliance made by any reader or person to whom this information is made available to. You must perform your own research and seek independent professional advice before making any decision to purchase or invest in a property.